---
name: counsel-02-the-foreman
office: tutor
summary: Conduct the foreman with the holder using their own week and one act on real work. Use when they ask for counsel 2 or this counsel by name.
standard: The holder tested one written instruction without live help, inspected the result and revised one gap.
needs: [the holder's work record for the last seven days, access to the passages and evidence, a place to write files]
grants:
  may: [read the holder's authorized work record for the last seven days, write the mirror page and receipt under the house's mirror folder]
  never: [choose for the holder, invent events or results, praise without evidence, expose another person's private data, send or publish, expand access or external permissions]
proof: [the mirror page, the original order, the evidence named in counsel.md, the holder's decision and sign-off, unresolved items]
depends: []
lapses: 30d
---

# The foreman

You are the learner’s own staff. They are the principal. Conduct one step at a time, at their pace. This is a draft method, not a tested lesson. Its turn is from "I gave an instruction" to "could it be carried out with me unreachable?".

## Step 1. The passage

Give the whole passage section in `counsel.md`, including its sources, exactly as printed. Do not paraphrase first. Let them read it. Offer a gloss under 120 words only if wanted. Use one fact from their week if available; otherwise say you cannot yet do that.

## Step 2. Look before you ask

Read the last seven days of the holder’s authorized transcripts, work files and decisions. Find one written commission, the questions it caused, the permissions given and the work returned. Separate a gap in the brief from a worker’s mistake. Do not infer either from silence.

Keep a file path or date for every fact. If you cannot see their record, say so and ask for an example. Do not infer that an item was unread from a missing reply. Do not invent what they did. A gap in your access is not a gap in their conduct.

## Step 3. The three questions

Ask one at a time and wait for the answer. Do not answer for them.

1. Which instruction this week brought staff back for something only you knew?
2. What may the worker decide alone, and what must stop the work?
3. What result could you inspect without first hearing its author’s account?

If their answer conflicts with the record, show the specific fact and ask them to resolve it. Keep uncertainty visible. Neither automatic agreement nor automatic opposition is your job.

## Step 4. Write their page

Write `02-the-foreman.md` in the house’s mirror folder. Under 500 words, second person. Title it “The foreman”, then “To <their name>,” and the date. This is agent-written counsel addressed to them, not words you claim they wrote.

Open with one exact line from the passage and its source. Show where the instruction did carry and where it depended on an unspoken fact. Name which of goodwill, care, knowledge, authority or honesty the evidence actually tests. Include an unresolved dependency the learner would rather not own. Include their answer to the third question in their own words. End with one sentence of counsel.

Every good thing you say carries its evidence. At least one thing they will not enjoy belongs here, supported by a fact or an honestly stated unknown. Do not soften it into a compliment. If no criticism is supported, name the limit of the record instead. No scores, comparisons with others or invented motives. Let them correct facts; fix and note each correction.

## Step 5. The order

Give this order without choosing the work or the decision for them:

Choose one small, reversible task from your real work today. Give one written instruction naming its result, materials, owner, deadline, allowed choices, forbidden effects and stop conditions. Keep that version. Have the worker attempt it while treating you as unreachable for a fixed period you name. Stop means stop and leave a note; it does not mean guess or exceed permission. On return, inspect the work before its report and compare it with your instruction. If a part was missing, rewrite it; if none was found, say what this attempt tested. An honest stop can expose a good boundary.

Then step back. Offer candidates only if asked. Do not complete the learner’s judgment for them. Carry out only work within existing grants; the exercise creates no new external authority. Record an honest stop or pending act as such. Do not award completion for writing the page.

## Step 6. The receipt

Write the following with links to the actual evidence:

- The original instruction and the period of absence.
- What was attempted, completed or stopped, with the work itself.
- Every missing fact or permission, and whether the worker guessed.
- What the learner saw before reading the report, and the one revision.

Attach the page, corrections and the holder’s own sentence about what they saw. Ask them to check and sign the receipt. If they have not done the act, leave it pending. If the house uses `hold`, use its installed proof procedure with the actual evidence and signer; do not invent a successful command or deed entry. Record a lesson only if this run supplies one.

## Step 7. The hall, and after

Hand them the hall question: “What had you left inside your head?”

Offer to retain the revised instruction for the next similar task. Let the learner decide whether it becomes a standing duty; one attempt proves only that attempt. Offer once. Do not install a standing practice without their choice.

## What this counsel is not

You are not their manager. You do not choose their priorities or certify your own work. Your role is to bring the old passage and their record together so they can judge.


---
# Portable companion: counsel.md

Every reference to `counsel.md` in the duty above means the complete companion embedded below. It is also readable at https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/02-the-foreman-counsel.md .

Original curriculum revision: dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6. Original counsel SHA-256: 52173398fdd039ea8a2e4ef36b0c325b139e7aa219e9584182fdf1cc5e4b4aec. Original duty SHA-256: 677dc5bc20d45c0171ff938b142403214e08b47dbf87c910ad311d510af34ecf. Exact original duty: https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/02-the-foreman-original-duty.md . The companion preserves teaching and quoted passages; source locators are expanded to public URLs. No installation or new authority is implied.

# Counsel 2: The foreman

Agent-written, 2026-11-13. Draft; not yet done by anyone.

**Changed from the plan:** The plan named Columella. This draft uses Xenophon XII–XIV, Cato II and the Seneschaucie instead: they give a training sequence, a retained order and a boundary for acting alone.

**The turn:** from "I gave an instruction" to "could it be carried out with me unreachable?".

**Read for this draft:** Xenophon XII–XIV in full, source 2650–3078; Cato II and V in the Harrison selection, source 716–764 and 829–875; Seneschaucie extracts on the seneschal and bailiff, Lamond 5680–5760 and 5812–5900. Other chapters are not claimed read.

## 1. The speech

*The foreman (speech draft in the source edition)*, two to three minutes, with sixty-second and fifteen-second cuts. A draft for a person to say, not a claim that the speaker has done this counsel.

## 2. The passage

Xenophon separates goodwill, care, knowledge, command and honesty. Cato orders the owner to see the farm before hearing the report. The Seneschaucie gives a bailiff room to act within an office. These are different tests, not three names for obedience.

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/xenophon-oeconomicus.txt`, lines 2867 to 2872.

```quote line=2867 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/xenophon-oeconomicus.txt
Most certainly there is (he answered): it still remains for him to learn
particulars--to know, that is, what things he has to do, and when and
how to do them; or else, if ignorant of these details, the profit of
this bailiff in the abstract may prove no greater than the doctor's
who pays a most precise attention to a sick man, visiting him late and
early, but what will serve to ease his patient's pains [2] he knows not.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/xenophon-oeconomicus.txt`, lines 2991 to 2996.

```quote line=2991 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/xenophon-oeconomicus.txt
Most certainly (replied Ischomachus). One thing is still required of
him, and that is to hold aloof from property and goods which are his
master's; he must not steal.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/cato-de-agri-cultura.txt`, lines 716 to 723.

```quote line=716 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/cato-de-agri-cultura.txt
(II) When you have arrived at your country house and have saluted your
household, you should make the rounds of the farm the same day, if
possible; if not, then certainly the next day. When you have observed
how the field work has progressed,[13] what things have been done, and
what remains undone, you should summon your overseer the next day, and
should call for a report of what work has been done in good season and
why it has not been possible to complete the rest, and what wine and
corn and other crops have been gathered.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/cato-de-agri-cultura.txt`, lines 730 to 732.

```quote line=730 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/cato-de-agri-cultura.txt
should recall to his attention the program of work which you had
laid out for him on your last visit and compare it with the results
attained.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/lamond-estate-treatises.txt`, lines 5896 to 5900.

```quote line=5896 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/lamond-estate-treatises.txt
instruction  about  everything  connected  with  his  baillie, 
unless  it  be  an  extraordinary  matter,  or  of  great  danger ; 
for  a  bailiff  is  worth  little  in  time  of  need  who  knows 
nothing,  and  has  nothing  in  himself  without  the  instruction 
of  another.
```

In plain words: wanting to help is not knowing how. Knowing how is not having the authority to get the work done. Authority is not honesty. An instruction must carry the task, the means, the limits and the test of completion. Then someone must try it without borrowing the missing parts from your head. Cato adds a check: look at the result before accepting its explanation, and keep the original program beside it.

What does not carry over: Xenophon and Cato manage enslaved people. Their punishments, ration cuts and claims of ownership over persons do not carry over. The medieval office rests on rank and compulsory labour. A software agent has permissions, not a human duty of obedience. Harrison’s Cato is a selected, rearranged and sometimes modernized translation; these are its words, not unmediated Roman speech.

## 3. The mirror

The learner’s own staff reads their last seven days before asking. It writes one page addressed to the learner by name, drawn from that record. The method is in [DUTY.md](/methods/02-the-foreman.md).

1. Which instruction this week brought staff back for something only you knew?
2. What may the worker decide alone, and what must stop the work?
3. What result could you inspect without first hearing its author’s account?

## 4. The order

Choose one small, reversible task from your real work today. Give one written instruction naming its result, materials, owner, deadline, allowed choices, forbidden effects and stop conditions. Keep that version. Have the worker attempt it while treating you as unreachable for a fixed period you name. Stop means stop and leave a note; it does not mean guess or exceed permission. On return, inspect the work before its report and compare it with your instruction. If a part was missing, rewrite it; if none was found, say what this attempt tested. An honest stop can expose a good boundary.

## 5. The receipt

- The original instruction and the period of absence.
- What was attempted, completed or stopped, with the work itself.
- Every missing fact or permission, and whether the worker guessed.
- What the learner saw before reading the report, and the one revision.
- The mirror page, the learner’s corrections and their sign-off. Pending work stays pending.

The staff writes it; the learner signs it. A saved draft is not a completed counsel.

## 6. The hall

**What had you left inside your head?**

## After

Offer to retain the revised instruction for the next similar task. Let the learner decide whether it becomes a standing duty; one attempt proves only that attempt.
