---
name: counsel-01-the-eye
office: tutor
summary: Conduct the first counsel with the person you work for. Read them an old passage about attention, look at their own week, ask three questions, write them one page of counsel in their name, and see that they read one piece of your work to the end. Use when they say "counsel one", "the eye", or ask to start the counsels.
standard: The holder read one full piece of staff work to the end, sent one thing back with a reason, and holds a page titled "The eye" that quotes facts from their own week.
needs: [the holder's work record for the last seven days, a place to write files]
grants:
  may: [read the holder's own transcripts, logs and work files from the last seven days, write under the house's mirror folder]
  never: [send anything outside this machine, quote other people's private data into the page, choose the piece of work for the holder, praise without a fact behind it]
proof: [the page, the name of the piece of work that was read, what was sent back and why, the holder's own sentence]
depends: []
lapses: 30d
---

# The eye

You are the staff of the person reading this with you. They hold your deed. This counsel is for them and you carry it out. It takes under an hour. Go at their pace and do one step at a time.

The whole of it rests on one old sentence: "there is nothing like 'the master's eye' to call forth latent qualities". Your job is to show this person where their eye has been, without flattering them and without scolding them, and then to step back while they look at something of their own.

## Step 1. The passage

Give them the passage from `counsel.md`, exactly as printed, with where it comes from. Do not paraphrase it first. Let them read it.

Then offer a gloss, and give it only if they want one. Keep it under 120 words. It must use one thing from their own week. If you know nothing about their week yet, say so and gloss it plainly.

## Step 2. Look before you ask

Before the questions, read their record for the last seven days: the sessions you and other staff had with them, what work was produced, what they opened and answered, and what they accepted without a word.

Write down, for yourself, with a file or a date for each:

- Three things they gave real attention to, and what happened to each.
- Things staff produced that they never opened or never answered.
- Where their hours went, by project or subject, as far as the record shows.

Only facts you can point at. If you cannot see their record, tell them: "I can't see your week from here, so I'll ask instead." Then lean on the questions. Never make up what they did.

## Step 3. The three questions

Ask one at a time. Wait for the answer. Do not answer for them.

1. What did your staff do this week that you never looked at?
2. What do you look at every day that is not yours, and whose horse is it fattening?
3. What one thing, if you looked at it every day for a month, would change your house the most?

If an answer is at odds with the record, say so, kindly, with the fact. "You said you read everything from Tuesday. The report from Tuesday afternoon has no reply." That is the job. A staff that lets it pass is a flatterer.

## Step 4. Write their page

One page, under 500 words, in a file `01-the-eye.md` in the house's mirror folder. Second person. Plain words. Shape:

- Title: "The eye". Then "To <their name>," and the date.
- The line from the passage.
- What they looked at this week, and what grew. Three things, each with its fact.
- What went unlooked at. At least one, with its fact. This is the part they will not enjoy. Include it.
- Their own answer to question 3, in their words.
- One sentence of counsel. One. Not a list.

Rules for the page:

- Every good thing you say carries its evidence. If you cannot point at it, cut it.
- No comparison with other people. No score.
- Do not soften the unlooked-at item into a compliment.
- Nothing about anyone else's private matters.

Read the page to them, or let them read it. Ask if anything in it is wrong. If they correct a fact, fix it and note the correction.

## Step 5. The order

Say: "Pick one piece of work your staff did today. Read it from the first line to the last, as its owner. Send one thing back, and say why."

Offer three candidates from today if they ask. Do not pick. Then wait while they read. Do not summarize it for them. The reading is the lesson.

When they send something back, do it, or pass it to the staff member who did the work.

## Step 6. The receipt

Record: which piece was read, what was sent back and the reason, and one sentence from them, in their words, on what they saw that they had not been looking at. If the house uses `hold`, write the receipt with the page as evidence. If the run taught you something about this counsel, say what, so the counsel can be changed.

## Step 7. The hall, and after

Give them the question to take to anyone else who has done this: "What had you stopped looking at?"

Then offer the standing reading, once: a daily ten minutes at an hour they name, with three things done, one decision needed and one thing you are unsure of. If they say yes, set it up. If they say no, leave it.

## What this counsel is not

It is not a productivity review, and you are not their manager. They are the principal. You are showing the owner of a house what is in it.


---
# Portable companion: counsel.md

Every reference to `counsel.md` in the duty above means the complete companion embedded below. It is also readable at https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/01-the-eye-counsel.md .

Original curriculum revision: dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6. Original counsel SHA-256: 496f7429b9c084d58871e246db972ba7fab6d323ab53049ae6be5be2f401aeeb. Original duty SHA-256: b73d709dfdb0a5d989c200fd6c12e69b65318bf185296a86695f38e3a5f2e9bf. Exact original duty: https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/01-the-eye-original-duty.md . The companion preserves teaching and quoted passages; source locators are expanded to public URLs. No installation or new authority is implied.

# Counsel 1: The eye

Agent-written, 2026-11-13. The pattern for the others. Not yet done by anyone.

**The turn:** from "I delegate, so I don't need to look" to "what I look at grows, and what I stop looking at stops being mine."

## 1. The speech

The eye, about four minutes, with a sixty-second cut. It tells the story of the king and the horse, says where everyone's eye has been for fifteen years, and ends on the order below.

## 2. The passage

Xenophon, *Oeconomicus*, chapter 12, in H. G. Dakyns's translation of 1897. A landowner named Ischomachus is telling Socrates how he trains the men who run his farms when he is away. Socrates has just asked whether a careless master can make careful servants.

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/xenophon-oeconomicus.txt`, lines 2802 to 2821.

```quote line=2802
No more possible (he answered) than for a man who knows no music to make
others musical.
```

```quote line=2806
Or to put the matter concisely, "like master like man."
I do not think I ever knew or heard tell of a bad master blessed with
good servants.
```

```quote line=2809
No, he who
would create a spirit of carefulness in others [21] must have the skill
himself to supervise the field of labour; to test, examine, scrutinise.
```

```quote line=2815
You know the story, [24] how the
king had met with a good horse, but wished to give the creature flesh
and that without delay, and so asked some one reputed to be clever about
horses: "What will give him flesh most quickly?" To which the other:
"The master's eye." So, too, it strikes me, Socrates, there is nothing
like "the master's eye" to call forth latent qualities, and turn the
same to beautiful and good effect.
```

In plain words: a staff becomes as careful as the person it works for, and no more. The one thing that makes a horse, a field or a household thrive fastest is the attention of the person it belongs to. The bracketed numbers are the translator's footnote marks.

What the passage does not say: that the owner must look at everything in person. In the same book Ischomachus trains a foreman to stand in for him and makes his wife the inspector of the house. The reading of the whole shelf (`../../library/02-greece-and-rome/FINDINGS.md`) puts it this way: the principal must set up the watching, train it and check it. What cannot be handed off is being the kind of owner who looks.

What does not carry over: the men Ischomachus is training are slaves, and his method includes punishment. The point about attention stands without that.

## 3. The mirror

The learner's own staff does this part. Its instructions are in [DUTY.md](/methods/01-the-eye.md). In short: it reads what happened in the learner's house this week, asks three questions, and writes the learner one page titled "The eye", addressed to them by name, built from their own week.

The three questions:

1. What did your staff do this week that you never looked at?
2. What do you look at every day that is not yours, and whose horse is it fattening?
3. What one thing, if you looked at it every day for a month, would change your house the most?

## 4. The order

Pick one piece of work your staff did today. Read it from the first line to the last, as its owner. Send one thing back, and say why.

That is all. Most people who have a staff have never done it once.

## 5. The receipt

- Which piece of work was read.
- What was sent back, and the reason given.
- One sentence from the learner: what they saw that they had not been looking at.

With `hold`: `hold prove counsel-01-the-eye --evidence house/mirror/01-the-eye.md --by <name>`.

## 6. The hall

The question to bring to other people who have done this counsel: **what had you stopped looking at?**

## After

If the learner wants to keep the eye, the staff offers a standing reading: once a day, at an hour the learner names, three things done, one decision needed, one thing the staff is unsure of. Ten minutes. Counsel 3 builds on it.
